Rate Your Immigration Judge

  • Find and Rate Your Immigration Judge
  • Blog
  • Resources
Menu
  • Find and Rate Your Immigration Judge
  • Blog
  • Resources

Hon. Mary C. Baumgarten, Immigration Judge, Buffalo Immigration Court

4 Reviews
Add Photos
Rate This Judge / Califica a Este Juez

About the Immigration Judge

Then-Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker appointed Mary C. Baumgarten to begin hearing cases in March 2019. Judge Baumgarten earned a Bachelor of Science in 1985 from the University of Notre Dame and a Juris Doctor in 1989 from the State University of New York at Buffalo Law School. From 1989 to 1995, Judge Baumgarten served as an associate at Nixon Hargrave Devaus & Doyle. From 1995 to 2002, she served as an assistant attorney general for the New York State Office of the Attorney General. From 2002 to 2004, she served as a law clerk under the Honorable William M. Skretny, U.S. District Court, Western District of New York. From 2004 to 2007, she served as a confidential law clerk for the Honorable Erin M. Peradotto, Appellate Division, 4th Department. From 2007 through 2018, she served as an assistant U.S. attorney in the Western District of New York. Judge Baumgarten is a member of the New York Bar.

Rate This Judge / Califique a Este Juez

Sort By

  1. Anonymous
    Knowledge of Facts / Conocimiento del caso

    Knowledge of Law / Conocimiento de la ley

    On-Time / A Tiempo

    Courtesy / Cortesía

    Fairness / Justicia

    Patience / Paciencia

    Dignified / Digno

    Temperament & Composure / Temperamento

    Rude, obnoxious and no civility towards prepared defense counsel. Should be removed without thought.

    4 months ago
  2. Anonymous
    Knowledge of Facts / Conocimiento del caso

    Knowledge of Law / Conocimiento de la ley

    On-Time / A Tiempo

    Courtesy / Cortesía

    Fairness / Justicia

    Patience / Paciencia

    Dignified / Digno

    Temperament & Composure / Temperamento

    Undignified, impatient, angry, rude, ignorant of the law, and overall a huge displeasure to appear before. Former prosecutor with US Attorney’s Office; extremely dismissive of defense counsel. Shrill voice and ugly inside and out. Should be fired immediately.

    8 months ago
  3. Anonymous
    Knowledge of Facts / Conocimiento del caso

    Knowledge of Law / Conocimiento de la ley

    On-Time / A Tiempo

    Courtesy / Cortesía

    Fairness / Justicia

    Patience / Paciencia

    Dignified / Digno

    Temperament & Composure / Temperamento

    Zero patience, very aggressive

    9 months ago
  4. Anonymous
    Knowledge of Facts / Conocimiento del caso

    Knowledge of Law / Conocimiento de la ley

    On-Time / A Tiempo

    Courtesy / Cortesía

    Fairness / Justicia

    Patience / Paciencia

    Dignified / Digno

    Temperament & Composure / Temperamento

    This judge has no experience in immigration law and simply does not know the law with respect to the Immigration and Nationality Act. She should be removed immediately

    12 months ago

Your review will appear shortly

Please review only once unless you have a new experience with this judge

Do:

  • Review and comment based on your own experience

 

Dont’:

  • Use Inappropriate Language: Including threats, harassment, lewdness, hate speech or displays of bigotry.
  • Relevance: Reviews are not a place to promote,  talk about your political ideologies, or other matters that don’t address your own experience with an immigration judge.
  • Privacy: Don’t publicize private information.

Why Is Your Honest Review So Important

Rate Your Immigration Judge is an important source of information for other immigrants and their attorneys, but also for the immigration judges.

Your honest review allows judges to receive an assessment of their work, and to hopefully make adjustments so that at the end of the day, we have a more uniform application of the laws and regulations, with fairness, courtesy and compassion in all our immigration courts across the United States.

Copyright Rate Your Immigration Judge © 2022. All Rights Reserved

Login

Register |  Lost your password?